America just handed its leaders a report card. Sooner or later, your team will hand you one too. Here’s how great leaders respond.
The verdict always comes
This week, millions of Americans voted in the midterm elections. Whatever you think of US politics, and I’m not here to tell you what to think, there’s a leadership lesson sitting right in the middle of it.
The midterms are a mid-term performance review. Two years in, the people get a say on how their leaders are going. History says the result is rarely kind: the party holding the White House has lost seats in almost every modern midterm. Not because every leader failed. Because people judge the gap between what they were promised and what they’re living.
Here’s the thing. Every leader gets a midterm. Yours might not come with ballot boxes and cable news panels. It comes as an engagement survey. A 360. A resignation from someone you thought was happy. A project review where the room goes quiet.
I know what it feels like to get a verdict you didn’t want. Years ago, as a sole parent, I faced around 40 job rejections in a row. Forty times, someone looked at me and said not you, not now. I could have explained every one of them away. Instead, I listened, I got clear on what I had to offer, and I built LeadershipHQ from scratch.
The verdict is never the end of the story. What you do next is.
1. Results are feedback, not an attack
Watch any election night and you’ll see two kinds of response. Some leaders say: we hear you, we’ve got work to do. Others say: the turnout was off, the media was unfair, the voters didn’t understand.
We do exactly the same thing at work. The engagement score drops and we blame the timing of the survey. The 360 stings and we decide the raters had an agenda. It’s human. It’s also how leaders stay stuck.
Great leaders treat the verdict as data. They get curious before they get defensive. They ask three questions:
- What is this telling me that I didn’t want to hear?
- Where’s the gap between what I intended and what people experienced?
- What’s one thing I’ll do differently, starting this week?
The leaders who bounce back fastest aren’t the ones who never get bad news. They’re the ones who go looking for it before it arrives.
2. People vote on what they feel, not on your strategy deck
In the lead-up to these midterms, one issue kept rising to the top on both sides of politics: the cost of living. Vision, policy and messaging all mattered less than what people felt at the checkout and in the rent payment.
Your team is exactly the same. They don’t judge you on the strategy on slide 12. They judge you on how Tuesday afternoon feels. Is the workload sane? Do they know what matters? Does anyone notice when they’re stretched? Are they quietly worried about money, their job, their kids?
We’re feeling this in Australia right now too. Cost-of-living pressure doesn’t stay at home. It walks into your meetings, sits in your one-on-ones, and shows up as tiredness, short tempers and disengagement.
Human leaders close the gap between the big picture and the lived experience. They ask, “How is this actually landing for you?” and they stay for the answer.
3. Grace in winning and losing
Some of the most powerful leadership moments in any election aren’t the victory speeches. They’re the concessions. The candidate who picks up the phone, congratulates their opponent, and wishes them well in the job, while their own supporters are hurting in the room behind them.
That takes courage. It means putting something bigger than your ego first.
At work, you’ll lose too. The restructure you argued against goes ahead. The promotion goes to someone else. Your idea gets knocked back in front of the exec team. Your people are watching how you handle it, and they’ll copy you.
And when you win? Grace matters even more. Thank the people who disagreed with you. Bring them back in. The way you win tells your team whether it’s safe to challenge you next time.
How do you lose in front of your team? It’s one of the best questions a leader can ask.
4. Listen for the people who didn’t vote
Unlike Australia, voting in the US isn’t compulsory, and midterm turnout tends to be low. In 2022, around 46% of eligible Americans voted. In 2018, a record year, it was about 50%. Half the country, in other words, often says nothing at all.
Every workplace has its non-voters. The people who skip the survey. The ones who nod in the meeting and say nothing. The quiet high performer who’s already updating their LinkedIn profile.
Silence isn’t agreement. Often it’s a sign people have stopped believing their voice will change anything. And just like an election, the people who stay quiet still shape the outcome, usually by walking out the door.
So don’t just read the feedback you get. Ask who isn’t giving it, and why. Make it safe, simple and worth their while to speak up.
Your midterm reflection
Take ten minutes this week with these:
- If your team voted on your leadership today, what would the result be? Be honest.
- When did you last get feedback you didn’t like, and what did you do with it?
- What’s the gap between what you think you’re delivering and what your people actually feel?
- How do you behave when you lose? How about when you win?
- Who on your team has gone quiet, and when did you last ask them why?
You don’t have to wait for the verdict. The best leaders call their own midterm early.
Call your own midterm
That’s exactly why I built Worksparks. Real-time leadership. Real results.
For you: Worksparks is your AI leadership coach, there whenever you need to think through a tough conversation, a hard piece of feedback or a decision that’s keeping you up at night. It’s A$29 a month, with a 14-day free trial. [Start your free trial at worksparks.com]
For your leaders: The Human Leader Index™ 360 is coming soon, powered by Worksparks. It shows leaders what their people actually see across seven areas, from composure and care to courage, delivery and impact. Every 360 comes with a coach debrief, because data without a conversation changes nothing.
We’re offering founding partner places to the first three organisations, with delivery in February and March 2027. Places close 31 January 2027. Reply to this newsletter or email hello@worksparks.com to grab one.
Don’t wait for the verdict. Go and ask for it. Sonia